Pachyphytum machucae

Help me identify this plant. There are 3 different succulents, the two pink ones and the one with the green leaf. @KelsiBriana @DonNotDonny @Yollymac

Pink ones are probably Echeveria laui and that green one seems like kalanchoe

Very pretty

@jyotu, with due respect, please be careful to not incorrectly identify plants, one incorrect identified plant can lead to hundreds following suit, which we end up needing to clean up. This affects the integrity of the app for all users unfortunately.

the pink one is beautiful. also... we’re all doing the best we can with identification..

I used probably because I'm not sure what is it @Yollymac

@jyotu Thanks for helping:) I think the Echeveria laui has flatter leaves, but I've been told it is difficult to ID it 100% until it flowers. With the weather that I have in Canada, our summer season is so short , my succulents don't often have enough sun exposure to flower.

@matewe, @columbiariver thanks! I picked these leaves off the floor in a hardware store, I am proud that they have survived and grown into real plants.☺

@lissoms. Thanks, most of my succulents are green, so I really appreciate the pink ones.😊

@KelsiBriana I believe you are right! I didn't realize that the Pachyphytum machucae, common name Moonstone? came in blue AND pink. Are they both considered Moonstone? In my picture, I think that's the pink one with the rounded leaves, towards the right.

@Yollymac, like most of my succulents, I'm going to have to wait patiently for them to flower before I correctly identify them!😊

Actually @KelsiBriana Pachyphytum Redowski is commonly known as baby fingers. In Australia Redowski is commonly and incorrectly sold as Machucae because Asian countries call them baby fingers. If we examine this plant in the ICN and not by Google images, I do not believe this is in fact Machucae, also not a plant you would likely find lying in a hardware store. In any event, I am keeping an eye out for a possible ID. It's a beautiful plant.